ETFs vs Stocks: Which is the Smarter Way to Start Investing?

Investing is a lot like choosing what to eat. You can go to a buffet, where you can sample a little bit of everything (fresh salads, starters, various cuisines, and desserts) without committing to just one. Or… you can order à la carte, choosing individual dishes one by one, with each dish having its own unique flavours and risks. 

The same goes for your investments: you can choose an Exchange-Traded Fund (ETF), which gives you a little bit of everything by investing in multiple assets, or you can pick individual stocks, which allow you to focus on specific companies.

But which option is better for you? Let's try and make the decision easier.

What is an ETF and How Does It Work?

An Exchange-Traded Fund (ETF) is a type of security that tracks an index (like the Nifty 50 or Sensex), a commodity (like gold), bonds, or a mix of assets. The goal of an ETF is simple: mimic the performance of the index or assets it represents.

For example, a Nifty 50 ETF invests in the same 50 companies that make up the Nifty 50 Index. If the index rises, so does the ETF. And if it falls, the ETF follows suit. Here's how ETFs work:

• Traded like stocks: You can buy and sell ETFs on stock exchanges like the NSE or BSE throughout the trading day, just like you would with individual stocks. Their prices fluctuate based on market demand and supply.
• NAV Link: The ETF's trading price is closely tied to the Net Asset Value (NAV) of its underlying assets, ensuring alignment with the index or assets it tracks.

ETFs in India have been around since 2002, with the first ETF launched by Nippon India Mutual Fund, tracking the Nifty 50. Since then, they've gained immense popularity for their simplicity and cost-effectiveness.

Similarities Between ETFs and Stocks

Even though ETFs and stocks differ in many ways, they share several similarities, making it easy for investors to transition between them.

1. Exchange-traded: Like stocks, ETFs are traded on exchanges, allowing investors to buy or sell them during market hours.
2. Real-time pricing: Both offer intraday trading, meaning you can track and trade at real-time prices. Mutual Funds, by contrast, are priced only once a day.
3. Investment clarity: With stocks, you know exactly which company you're investing in. Similarly, with ETFs, you can easily track the performance of the underlying assets because they are disclosed regularly, providing transparency.

While ETFs and stocks have a lot in common, the differences between them are what determine which one might be better for you.

Key Differences Between ETFs and Stocks

Here's a detailed comparison of ETFs and stocks to help you understand their distinct characteristics:

ETFs spread your money across many investments, making them less risky and easier to manage, while stocks focus on a single company, offering higher return potential but with more risk and effort. Now that you know the core differences, let’s dive into the pros and cons of investing in stocks.

The Pros and Cons of Stocks

Pros of Investing in Stocks:

1. Potential for high returns: Especially when invested in fast-growing sectors like technology, pharmaceuticals, or consumer goods. For example, Infosys has delivered a Compound Annual Growth Rate (CAGR) of 14% over the past 10 years, showcasing the power of long-term stock investments.
2. Liquidity: You can buy and sell them easily during market hours. This flexibility gives investors the ability to react quickly to changing market conditions.
3. Ownership in companies: When you buy stocks, you own a part of the company. This means you get a share of the company's profits. For instance, Hindustan Unilever has been a consistent performer, with its net profit rising from ₹8,892 crore in FY2022 to ₹10,282 crore in FY2024.
4. Passive income: Many companies offer regular passive income to shareholders. Take ITC Ltd., which paid a dividend yield of around 4% in FY 2023. If you invested ₹1 lakh in ITC, you would have earned ₹4,000 just from dividends.

Cons of Investing in Stocks:

1. Market volatility: During uncertain times, the value of your stocks can fluctuate significantly, causing stress for investors.
2. Risk of losses: Particularly if you invest in companies that underperform or face financial difficulties. No stock, no matter how well-known, is immune to risk.
3. Need for research: Unlike Mutual Funds, which are managed by professionals, investing in stocks requires continuous monitoring. Investors must stay on top of the companies they invest in to track performance and identify potential risks.

For most other people, their busy schedules leave little time to track the performance of their investments. You, too, may not have the time or energy to track your stocks and pick new stocks regularly. Thus, there’s a pressing need to seek help from registered and trusted stock research houses.

Having professional analysts picking and tracking stocks for you can be really helpful, especially for those who aren't full-time stock analysts.

With Finology 30, our flagship basket, you get 30 long-term stocks picked and tracked by analysts in the Finology Research Desk throughout the year.

The Pros and Cons of ETFs

Pros of Investing in ETFs:

1. Diversification: Instead of putting all your money into one stock, an ETF spreads your investment across a range of securities. For example, the Nifty 50 ETF provides exposure to the top 50 companies listed on the NSE.
2. Lower costs: ETFs generally have lower expense ratios compared to actively managed Mutual Funds because they are passively managed. This means the management fees are lower, allowing you to keep more of your returns.
3. Liquidity: Like stocks, you can buy and sell ETFs during market hours. This makes them more liquid than Mutual Funds, which can only be bought or sold at the end of the trading day.
4. Transparency: ETFs regularly disclose their holdings, giving investors clarity. This transparency ensures that you know exactly what you're investing in and can easily track its performance.

Cons of Investing in ETFs:

1. Tracking error: Factors like fees, liquidity, and fund management can cause a small tracking error, meaning the ETF may not exactly match the performance of the index it tracks. For example, the Nifty BeES ETF has a tracking error of around 0.1% - 0.3%.
2. Market risk: If the market declines, so does the value of your ETF. During the COVID-19 market crash, the Nifty 50 ETF lost more than 23% of its value, reflecting the overall market downturn.
3. Trading costs: You may incur trading costs, such as brokerage fees when buying or selling ETFs. For example, trading the SBI Nifty ETF could incur a brokerage fee of around 0.05%-0.1% per trade.

Now comes the real question: Should you choose ETFs or stocks? 

ETFs vs Stocks: Which Is Right for You?

The answer depends on your financial goals, your willingness to take risks, and the time you’re ready to invest in managing your portfolio.

• When Stocks Are Better: If you have the time and expertise to analyse individual companies and are willing to take on more risk for potentially higher returns, stocks may be a better fit for you. 
• When ETFs Are Better: If you're new to investing or don't have the time or expertise to pick individual stocks, ETFs may be a better option. They provide instant diversification and a low-maintenance investment strategy.

If you're leaning toward stocks but feel lost among thousands of options, Finology 30 has your back. You get 30 thoroughly researched stocks designed for long-term investors, with buy/sell alerts, important updates, and a stress-free way to grow your wealth. Subscribe Now and start investing smarter!

Conclusion

Both ETFs and stocks have their unique advantages, and there's no one-size-fits-all solution. If you're just starting out, ETFs offer a low-maintenance and low-risk way to begin investing while still allowing you to build a diversified portfolio. If you're ready to take a more active role, individual stocks might give you the potential for higher returns.

No matter which route you choose, remember that consistency and research are key. Whether you're opting for the simplicity of ETFs or the excitement of picking individual stocks, the most important thing is to start early, stay disciplined, and always invest based on your financial goals.